Homicide will send shivers down the spine after a sudden incident. But it has some variations depending on the scenario. For instance, do you know what is culpable homicide? It is greatly significant in the trial.
As culpable homicide has a major legal classification in homicide cases, we will explain the definitions and differences regarding all types of homicide to understand this homicide better.
What is Homicide?
In its simplest form, homicide is the killing of one human being by another. When someone attempts and murder someone successfully, it’s called homicide. But, there are differences between lawful and unlawful homicides.
- Lawful homicide falls under the self-defence and defence of others
- Culpable homicide falls under the act of unlawful killings.
What is Culpable Homicide?
Culpable homicide is a legal term used in various isdictions, particularly those within the Commonwealth of Nations. It listed a range of unlawful killings that can be intentional, accidental, or due to negligence.
Essentially, culpable homicide refers to a situation where one person causes the death of another through a guilty act. Here is the definition of culpable homicide according to Section 222(1) of the Criminal Code of Canada:
“A person commits homicide when, directly or indirectly, by any means, he causes the death of a human being.”
The code states that a person commits culpable homicide when he kills someone—
- through an unlawful act
- by criminal negligence
- by threats or fear of violence or by fraudulence
- by willfully frightening a child, old or sick person
The Elements for Culpable Homicides
There must be some certain elements presented to classify a killing as a homicide. Those are causing death and culpable acts.
- Causing Death: The primary element is causing the death of another person.
- Culpable Act: The death must be a result of an act by the accused, becoming intentional, accidental, or negligent.
How The Law Determines Culpable Homicides of Different Types
The specific details of culpable homicide can change depending on the jurisdiction. In general, the law categorizes culpable homicides based on the level of culpability involved. These categories may include murder, voluntary manslaughter, and involuntary manslaughter.
- Murder: The most serious type, involving malice aforethought (premeditated intent to kill).
- Voluntary Manslaughter: Killing committed in the heat of passion due to provocation.
- Involuntary Manslaughter: Unintentional killing arising from recklessness or negligence.
Culpable Homicide vs. Manslaughter vs. Murder
Culpable homicide is a broad category. Especially manslaughter and murder are specific types of unlawful killings that fall within it. But we will now spotlight the three acts’ features for easy understanding.
| Murder | Manslaughter | Culpable Homicide |
|
|
|
Common Ingredients of Culpable Homicide, Murder, and Manslaughter
Despite their differences, all three share some common elements:
- The causing of death.
- An unlawful act by the accused.
- The Bridge between Murder and Culpable Homicide
Culpable homicide acts as a bridge between murder and other forms of unlawful killings. It acknowledges that death occurred due to a guilty act, but the level of intent needs further examination to determine if it falls under murder or a less severe offence.
Culpable Homicide vs. Manslaughter: Know the Difference
The difference between culpable homicide and manslaughter lies in the level of intent. Culpable homicide simply states that a culpable act caused a death. On the other hand, manslaughter specifies a reduced level of guilt compared to murder. Often, man slaughter happens due to provocation or lack of premeditation.
How Lawyers Defend the Culpable Murder case for client?
Even in a seemingly clear-cut culpable homicide case, a lawyer tries hard so that their client receives a fair trial. They apply some strategies to bring the most favourable outcome possible. Here’s a glimpse into their strategies:
Step 1: Investigate the Circumstances
The lawyer carefully examines the evidence, police reports, and witness statements. They may request additional investigations to identify mitigating factors.
Step 2: Explore Legal Defenses
Depending on the details, the lawyer explores potential defences like self-defence, involuntary manslaughter, or diminished capacity (mental state).
Step 3: Challenge the Prosecution’s Case
The lawyer scrutinizes the prosecution’s evidence, looking for weaknesses or errors in procedure that could cast doubt on their case.
Step 4: Negotiate a Plea Bargain
The lawyer might negotiate a plea bargain with the prosecution if a strong defence seems unlikely. This could result in a lesser charge or reduced sentence.
Step 5: Focus on Sentencing
Even if a conviction seems inevitable, the lawyer works hard to minimize the sentence by presenting positive aspects of the client’s character and background.
Conclusion
Overall, culpable homicide is a legal term explaining various forms of unlawful killings. If you ever face this accusation, you can mark yourself safe by understanding its elements and how it differentiates from murder and manslaughter. Consulting with a qualified legal agency is always recommended if you require more information.
FAQs
What is the Punishment for Culpable Homicide?
The punishment for culpable homicide relies on the specific type and jurisdiction. It can range from 5 to 25 years imprisonment to life, with some allowing for a fine. The key factors are intent and culpability. Acts with malicious intent might receive harsher sentences than unintentional murder.
What is a Culpable Homicide Example?
Imagine a driver speeds through a red light and hits a pedestrian; as a result, the pedestrian dies. Although the driver didn’t intend to kill him, his reckless act caused death. This could be considered a culpable homicide, possibly manslaughter, depending on the jurisdiction. If the driver was drunk while driving, the severity of the charge might increase.
What is the Difference Between Homicide and Culpable Homicide?
Homicide covers lawful killings (self-defence) and unlawful killing (intent). Culpable homicide narrows it down to unlawful killings where someone’s blameworthy actions caused the death. So, you can think of homicide as a broad category with culpable homicide as a specific type within it.
Is Culpable Homicide a Bailable Offence?
The bail for culpable homicide depends on jurisdiction. In India, culpable homicide is not bailable normally. The accused must stay in jail until trial for their lack of trust. But, a judge can decide the severity and type based on case details and grant bail.